Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa – Authentic Italian Dining with Rich Pasta & Cozy Ambiance
Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa brings authentic Italian flavors to a cozy, elegantly decorated space at 12045 5th St. Known for rich, perfectly cooked pastas like penne vodka and homemade gnocchi, this intimate trattoria delights with hearty, well-balanced dishes and standout creamy pesto sauces. The warm, attentive service and inviting atmosphere make it ideal for special occasions or casual meals alike. Frequent diners praise its consistent quality and reasonable prices, making it a cherished spot in Yucaipa’s dining scene. From classic desserts like tiramisu to friendly hospitality, Isabella’s truly captures the heart of Italian cuisine with every visit.
Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa at a glance
- Address 12045 5th St suite f, Yucaipa, CA 92399, United States
- Phone +1 909-797-2006
- Restaurant type Italian restaurant .
- Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .
Photos & Gallery
Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa: Reviews & Ratings
I finally got a chance to eat here for the first time today, and I was really happy with the quality, service, and overall price. The pasta was rich and cooked just right, and the Cabernet was very good and not overpriced. My only complaint is the house salad is a little basic with just lettuce and dressing. You can tell it is a converted coffee shop, but they did a good job with the decor and overall atmosphere. I plan on returning and will recommend to friends!
I had been a regular customer at the Isabella's location in Redlands for over 20 years; I was sad to see that it had closed but grateful that it reopened in Yucaipa. My daughter and I absolutely love Isabella's and we were both happy to return to a place that means so much to us. The new location is a little bit smaller, but has a very nice and comforting ambience. The food is still as delicious as it was when they were located in Redlands and the staff are all so amazing. So, if you're looking for a nice restaurant to have some delicious Italian food, definitely visit them as soon as you can.
It is so nice to have an elegant sit down Italian restaurant in town. The interior is decorated nicely and is a great place to celebrate a special occasion. The menu has a varied selection, so everyone should be able to find their favorites or try one of the specials. We have been here several times with several people, and all have enjoyed their meals. The desserts are delicious, like the creme brulee and tiramasu. The servers are always friendly, and the food is ready pretty quickly. Definitely will continue to keep coming back.
I am so excited that Isabella's is open here in Yucaipa. They have some of the best pasta dishes in the inland empire. They have a sister store that is in Redlands as well. I ate here for the lunch menu. The new build out is very intimate and was very well done. Smaller space so make sure you check it out before wait times get too long!! Our waitress was amazing and the staff greeted us so warmly when we arrived and left. I love the penne vodka and add chicken to it. My wife had the homemade gnocchi and also loved it.
My 1st time eating at Isabellas Trattoria. I was impressed with the greeting/hospitality when entering. I'm really into pesto. Their creamy pesto sauce was amazing. Our server was knowledgeable and observant. The atmosphere felt quaint. I spent less money at this upscale eatery than going to a fast food establishment. I will definitely be back.
Location
-
Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa12045 5th St suite f, Yucaipa, CA 92399, United States Hotline: +1 909-797-2006
Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa offers a heartfelt taste of Italy nestled in the heart of Yucaipa, California. This cozy Italian restaurant stands out for its rich, authentic pasta dishes, with the Spaghetti with Meatballs earning particular applause from patrons. The quality here is palpable—from perfectly cooked pasta to thoughtfully balanced sauces that celebrate traditional flavors without overwhelming the palate.
Stepping inside, you sense the warmth of a place that has carried its legacy from Redlands with grace. The intimate setting, though smaller, exudes a comforting, elegant atmosphere ideal for both everyday meals and special celebrations. The décor, carefully adapted from a former coffee shop, inspires a sense of charm without pretension, inviting guests to relax and savor their dining experience.
The service at Isabella's is consistently praised for its welcoming friendliness and attentive care, enhancing the overall enjoyment. Whether it’s the knowledgeable servers recommending the creamy pesto sauce or the smooth pairing of a well-priced cabernet, every detail feels anchored in genuine hospitality.
Dishes like the penne vodka with added chicken and homemade gnocchi showcase the kitchen’s skill in delivering Italian favorites with heart and precision. Even the desserts, such as the velvety creme brûlée and delicate tiramisu, leave a lasting impression, rounding out a truly satisfying meal.
Ultimately, Isabella's Trattoria Yucaipa is more than just a restaurant—it is a culinary retreat where tradition meets comfort, inviting guests to return time and again. If you seek authentic Italian fare served with warmth and consistency, this is a destination worth your visit.
Business Information
- Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Service options
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Delivery
- Payments
- Credit cards